Category:Album review

From Weezerpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
A one-star review for Pinkerton from the Dayton Daily News in Ohio, October 11, 1996.

This category organizes all the album reviews currently transcribed and posted on Weezerpedia. For song reviews, see here. To read a review, click on the link under the "Reviewer" category.

Weezer (The Blue Album)

Weezer (The Blue Album) (1994)
Weezer (The Blue Album) (1994) cover
Studio album by Weezer

Edit this template

Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Allmusic 5/5 stars5/5 stars5/5 stars5/5 stars5/5 stars (5/5) Not listed Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Amazon Not given Not listed Jim DeRogatis
Amazon (deluxe) Not given Not listed Jerry McCulley
BBC Not given March 1, 2004 Richard Banks
BlogCritics Not given September 14, 2008 Jon Jacobs
BlogCritics (deluxe) Not given July 1, 2004 Matthew Parten
IGN 9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars (9.0/10) April 16, 2004 Chris Carle
Rolling Stone Not given May 5, 1994 Paul Evans
Rolling Stone (deluxe) 4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars (4.0/5) April 19, 2004 Christian Hoard
Pitchfork Media 10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars (10.0/10) February 27, 2017 Jillian Maples

Pinkerton

Pinkerton (1996)
Pinkerton (1996) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Allmusic 5/5 stars5/5 stars5/5 stars5/5 stars5/5 stars (5/5) Not listed Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Amazon Not given Not listed Robert Burrow
CDUniverse Not given Not listed Unsigned
IGN 9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars9.5/10 stars (9.5/10) December 21, 2007 "JR"
Los Angeles Times 3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars (3.0/5) Unknown Unknown
NME 7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars (7.0/10) Unknown Unknown
The Onion A.V. Club Not given November 30, 2009 Josh Modell
Pitchfork Media 7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars (7.5/10) September, 1996 Ryan Schreiber
Pitchfork Media (Deluxe) 10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars10.0/10 stars (10.0/10) November 3, 2010 Ian Cohen
Q 4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars (4.0/5) Unknown Unknown
Rolling Stone (1996) 3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars (3.0/5) 1996 Rob O'Conner
Rolling Stone (2004) 5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars (5.0/5) December 9, 2004 Gavin Edwards
Spin 7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars (7.0/10) Unknown Unknown
Tiny Mix Tapes 5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars (5.0/5) Not listed "cowboy dan"
Dayton Daily News 1.0/5 stars1.0/5 stars1.0/5 stars1.0/5 stars1.0/5 stars (1.0/5) October 11, 1996 Ray Marcano
Stereogum No rating given April 21, 2016 Tom Breihan

Weezer (The Green Album)

Weezer (The Green Album) (2001)
Weezer (The Green Album) (2001) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Metacritic 7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars7.3/10 stars (73/100) Continuous Average score of collected album reviews
Allmusic 4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars (4.5/5) Not listed Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Amazon Not given Not listed Jaan Uhelszki
Drowned in Sound 9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars9.0/10 stars (9.0/10) May 14, 2001 Terry Bezer
Fazed 3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars (3.0/5) Not listed Matt Parks
IGN 7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars7.0/10 stars (7.0/10) December 21, 2007 "JR"
The Onion A.V. Club B+ May 15, 2001 Stephen Thompson
Pitchfork Media 4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars4.0/10 stars (4.0/10) May 14, 2001 Spencer Owen
PopMatters Not given May 15, 2001 Jason Thompson
NME 5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars (5.0/10) May 24, 2001 Sarah Dempster
Nude as the News Not given Not listed Jonathan Cohen
Rolling Stone 4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars (4.0/5) May 15, 2001 Rob Sheffield
Yahoo! 8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars8.0/10 stars (8.0/10) May 15, 2001 Ian Wade
Stereogum No rating given May 14, 2021 Nate Rogers

Maladroit

Maladroit
Maladroit cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Metacritic 7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars7.2/10 stars (72/100) Continuous Average score of collected album reviews
Allmusic 4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars (4/5) Not listed Stephen Thomas Erlewine
E! Online 8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars8.3/10 stars (B+; 83/100) Not listed Not listed
dotmusic 4.9/5 stars4.9/5 stars4.9/5 stars4.9/5 stars4.9/5 stars (4.0/5) May 30, 2002 Chris Heath
Pitchfork Media 5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars5.4/10 stars (5.4/10) May 27, 2002 Rob Mitchum
PopMatters Not given June 28, 2002 Jason Damas
Nude as the News Not given Not listed Jon Horowitz
Rolling Stone 4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars (4.0/5) May 9, 2002 Ann Powers
NME 4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars4.0/5 stars (4.0/5) September 12, 2005 (posted online) Mark Beaumont
Kerrang! 5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars5.0/5 stars (5.0/5) May 11, 2002 Ian Winwood

Make Believe

Make Believe (2005)
Make Believe (2005) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Metacritic 5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars (52/100) Continuous Average score of collected album reviews
Allmusic 4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars (4.5/5) Not listed Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Blender 3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars (3/5) Not listed Chris Norris
Dot Music 8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars (8/10) May 16, 2005 Chris Heath
E! Online 6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars (B-; 67/10) Not listed Not listed
The Guardian 3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars (3/5) May 5, 2005 Dave Simpson
IGN 9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars (9.3/10) May 9, 2005 (updated May 19, 2012) "JR"
NME No rating given September 12, 2005 Ian Winwood
Pitchfork Media 0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars (0.4/10) May 8, 2005 Rob Mitchum
Rolling Stone 4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars (4/5) May 19, 2005 Rob Sheffield
Stylus 3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars (D+; (33/100) May 13, 2005 Charles Merwin


Weezer (The Red Album)

Weezer (The Red Album) (2008)
Weezer (The Red Album) (2008) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Allmusic 4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars (4.5/5) Not listed Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Blender 2.5/5 stars2.5/5 stars2.5/5 stars2.5/5 stars2.5/5 stars (2.5/5) Not listed Tim Grierson
IGN 6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars6.9/10 stars (6.9/10) June 3, 2008 "JR"
NME 3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars (3.5/5) June 5, 2008 James McMahon
Pitchfork Media 4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars4.7/10 stars (4.7/10) June 2, 2008 Marc Hogan
Los Angeles Times 3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars (3/5) June 3, 2008 Richard Cromelin
Uncut 4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars (4/5) Unlisted Bud Scoppa
Hotpress 8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars (8/10) June 30, 2008 Paul Nolan
Billboard 7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars (7/10) Unlisted Lavinia Jones Wright
Boston Globe 7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars7/10 stars (7/10) June 3, 2008 Joan Anderman


Raditude

Raditude (2009)
Raditude (2009) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Metacritic 5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars5.7/10 stars (57/100) Continuous Average score of collected album reviews
Allmusic 3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars (3.5/5) Unlisted Matt Collar
Rolling Stone 3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars (3.5/5) November 2, 2009 Rob Sheffield
Pitchfork Media 4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars4.5/10 stars (4.5/10) November 4, 2009 Rob Mitchum
The New York Times No rating given November 1, 2009 Ben Ratliff
The Onion A.V. Club 5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars5.8/10 stars (C+; 58/100) November 3, 2009 Erik Adams
Slant Magazine 0.5/5 stars0.5/5 stars0.5/5 stars0.5/5 stars0.5/5 stars (0.5/5) October 28, 2009 Huw Jones
Tiny Mix Tapes 1.5/5 stars1.5/5 stars1.5/5 stars1.5/5 stars1.5/5 stars (1.5/5) Unlisted Jason P. Woodbury
Paste Magazine 3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars3.9/10 stars (3.9/10) November 6, 2009 Justin Jacobs


Hurley

Hurley (2010)
Hurley (2010) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Allmusic 3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars (3.5/5) Unlisted Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Pitchfork Media 5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars5.0/10 stars (5.0/10) September 17, 2010 Ian Cohen
Rolling Stone 3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars3.0/5 stars (3.0/5) September 14, 2010 Jon Dolan
Stereogum Mixed September 7, 2010 Jessica Suarez








Death to False Metal

Death to False Metal (2010)
Death to False Metal (2010) cover
Compilation album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Pitchfork Media 3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars3.5/10 stars (3.5/10) November 3, 2010 Ian Cohen
Allmusic 4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars (4/5) Unlisted Stephen Thomas Erlewine
The Onion A.V. Club 4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars4.2/10 stars (C-; 42/100) November 3, 2010 Austin L. Ray








Everything Will Be Alright in the End

Everything Will Be Alright in the End (2014)
Everything Will Be Alright in the End (2014) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Pitchfork Media 6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars6.5/10 stars (6.5/10) October 2, 2014 Ian Cohen
Rolling Stone 4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars (4/5) October 2, 2014 Caryn Ganz
Allmusic 4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars (4/5) Unlisted Stephen Thomas Erlewine
The Onion A.V. Club 7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars7.5/10 stars (B; 75/100) October 7, 2014 Evan Rytlewski
Stereogum Positive September 30, 2014 Michael Nelson








Weezer (The White Album)

Weezer (The White Album) (2016)
Weezer (The White Album) (2016) cover
Studio album by Weezer







Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Pitchfork Media 6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars6.2/10 stars (6.2/10) April 1, 2016 Zoe Camp
Allmusic 4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars (4.5/5) Unlisted Stephen Thomas Erlewine

Pacific Daydream

Pacific Daydream (2017)
Pacific Daydream (2017) cover
Studio album by Weezer








Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Pitchfork 4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars4.3/10 stars (4.3/10) October 26, 2017 Saby Reyes-Kulkarni
Allmusic 3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars3.5/5 stars (3.5/5) Unlisted Stephen Thomas Erlewine

Weezer (The Teal Album)

Weezer (The Teal Album) (2019)
Weezer (The Teal Album) (2019) cover
Studio album by Weezer








Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Allmusic 3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars (3/5) Unlisted Stephen Thomas Erlewine

Pages in category "Album review"

The following 103 pages are in this category, out of 103 total.

W