Category:Make Believe reviews

From Weezerpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Make Believe (2005)
Make Believe (2005) cover
Studio album by Weezer
Released May 10, 2005
Professional reviews

Metascore 52 / 100
Weezer chronology
Maladroit
(2002)
Make Believe
(2005)
Weezer (The Red Album)
(2008)

This category organizes all published reviews of Weezer's 5th album, Make Believe. To view all of Weezerpedia's album reviews, see here.

To read a review, click on the link under the Reviewer column in the table.

Reviewer Rating Review date Author
Metacritic 5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars5.2/10 stars (52/100) Continuous Average score of collected album reviews
Allmusic 4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars4.5/5 stars (4.5/5) Not listed Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Blender 3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars (3/5) Not listed Chris Norris
Dot Music 8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars8/10 stars (8/10) May 16, 2005 Chris Heath
E! Online 6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars6.7/10 stars (B-; 67/10) Not listed Not listed
The Guardian 3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars3/5 stars (3/5) May 5, 2005 Dave Simpson
IGN 9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars9.3/10 stars (9.3/10) May 9, 2005 (updated May 19, 2012) "JR"
NME No rating given September 12, 2005 Ian Winwood
Pitchfork Media 0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars0.4/10 stars (0.4/10) May 8, 2005 Rob Mitchum
Rolling Stone 4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars4/5 stars (4/5) May 19, 2005 Rob Sheffield
Stylus 3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars3.3/10 stars (D+; (33/100) May 13, 2005 Charles Merwin