Error creating thumbnail: File missing
⚠ SITE UNDERGOING SCHEDULED MAINTENANCE ⚠
We are currently in the process of updating to the latest version of MediaWiki, alongside numerous other improvements.
Editing will be disabled starting on April 19, 2024 at 12:00 ET.
Complete all edits and save all work before this time or progress may be lost.
Editing is scheduled to be re-enabled before the end of April.

Make Believe The Guardian record review

From Weezerpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Make Believe (2005)
Error creating thumbnail: File missing
Studio album by Weezer
Released May 10, 2005
Professional reviews

  • Allmusic
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (4.5/5)
  • Blender
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (3/5)
  • Dot Music
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (8/10)
  • E! Online
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (B-; 67/100)
  • The Guardian
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (3/5)
  • IGN
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (9.3/10)
  • Kerrang!
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
  • NME (No rating given)
  • Q Magazine
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
  • Pitchfork Media
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (0.4/10)
  • Rolling Stone
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (4/5)
  • Stylus Magazine
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    Error creating thumbnail: File missing
    (D+; 33/100)
  • See also: Make Believe song reviews

Metascore 52
Make Believe
Reviewer: Dave Simpson (The Guardian)
Publishing date: May 5, 2005
Rating: 3/5
Error creating thumbnail: File missing
Error creating thumbnail: File missing
Error creating thumbnail: File missing
Error creating thumbnail: File missing
Error creating thumbnail: File missing
(3/5)

Weezer have been off the scene for a while because front man Rivers Cuomo has been studying at Harvard, taking time out "to be a good person". In the meantime, their studied nerd-rock has taken something of an assault from sound-similar bands such as McFly and Busted who are actually, well, nerdish. Weezer's reply has been to up the sarcasm and wit to emphasise that much of what they do is at least heavily ironic. Lead-off single Beverley Hills[sic] manages to lambast both airhead ambition and the class system. The cheekily hilarious We Are All on Drugs snipes at dim-witted sophisticates who think loading up on narcotics and then telling everybody about it is such fun.

Elsewhere, there are familiar Weezer trademarks such as handclaps, bad cardigans, buzzsaw guitars, horn-rimmed glasses and at least one immaculate pastiche of Joan Jett's I Love Rock'n'Roll. Most curiously, a chunk of almost straight-faced love/self-doubt songs show that while these geeks may not inherit the earth, they can play their competitors at their own game.

— Dave Simpson, May 5, 2005

See also

External links