Talk:The 4 and 5 Star Demos of Rivers Cuomo

From Weezerpedia


We've added information to the wikitable that isn't on the original chart. Should we be doing this?
--MyNameIsJason 15:59, 24 October 2010 (EDT)

Also, the original chart has those old Alone I songs. --MyNameIsJason 16:07, 24 October 2010 (EDT)
I think it's probably best to keep updating the table with the current release info. The reason I made it a wikitable in the first place was so it could be more interactive and connected with the rest of the site. The screenshot of the original spreadsheet is still there as a photo in case anyone is interested in checking out the original version. Maybe a disclaimer explaining the updated release info would make it clear. Plus, I'm sure Rivers has an updated version of this spreadsheet that he still uses for tracking. --Brain seltzer 14:15, 25 October 2010 (EDT)
I think the wikitable is great. I don't think we should be adding new info, though. I think we should preserve it as it was. The page is about the spreadsheet. It isn't supposed to be a source of information for the songs beyond all the information that Cuomo originally gave. We have List of Weezer songs and List of Rivers Cuomo songs for organized tables of info about songs. Maybe we could have an updated version of it on a new page, with a little disclaimer like you said. Like it could be:

Note: The information on this table displays only the information that Rivers Cuomo entered into the spreadsheet that was released to fans. For an updated version of this chart, see here.
The 4 and 5 Star Demos of Rivers Cuomo
1 I Wish You Had an Axe Guitar Alone
2 Ain't Got No Words - Fuzz
3 The Answer Man - Fuzz
4 The Biggest Animal - Fuzz
5 Burn Yer Bridges - Fuzz
--MyNameIsJason 01:23, 27 October 2010 (EDT)
That sounds fine to me.--Brain seltzer 17:02, 28 October 2010 (EDT)