Template:Pinkerton reviews infobox data
- Allmusic
(5/5)
- Amazon (No rating given)
- CDUniverse (No rating given)
- IGN
(9.5/10)
- Los Angeles Times
(3.0/5)
- NME
(7.0/10)
- The Onion A.V. Club (No rating given)
- Pitchfork Media
(7.5/10)
- Pitchfork Media (Deluxe)
(10.0/10)
- Q
(4.0/5)
- Rolling Stone (1996)
(3.0/5)
- Rolling Stone (2004)
(5.0/5)
- Spin
(7.0/10)
- Tiny Mix Tapes
(5.0/5)
- Dayton Daily News
(1/5)
- Stereogum (No rating given)
- See also: Pinkerton song reviews